By SIA of NC | 🕒 4 min read | Published July 7th, 2025
Starting an insurance agency is an admirable goal—but it’s not always as simple or stress-free as some might expect. While the idea of being your own boss and setting your own schedule is appealing, it’s essential to understand the hard truths that come with building a business from the ground up. If you’re considering starting an insurance agency, setting realistic expectations will be key to your success.
You’re Not Just the Owner—You’re Everything
When launching a new agency, you’re not only the salesperson but also the service rep, the HR department, the janitor, and the strategic planner. Every role in your business falls to you, especially in the beginning. Even if you outsource tasks like bookkeeping or marketing, the responsibility still rests with you. If something isn’t done, you’re the one who has to pick up the slack.
Flexibility Exists—but So Does the Grind
Yes, owning your agency means you can occasionally attend a ball game or run errands mid-day—but that time has to be made up somewhere. Calls may come in at night, and claims never happen on a schedule. Expect long hours—many new agency owners work 60 to 80 hours a week during the startup phase. You may be doing business development during the day and planning operations or handling accounting tasks at night.
Stress is a Given—It’s How You Manage It That Matters
One of the biggest misconceptions? That starting a business will be less stressful. In reality, entrepreneurship brings its own set of pressures. From dealing with clients to managing carrier expectations and navigating compliance requirements, stress is part of the package. The key is learning how to manage it effectively. That’s where having a strategic partner—like SIA of NC—can make all the difference. Having a trusted advisor to provide support and guidance is often the relief valve business owners need.
Success Starts With Realistic Expectations
Starting an insurance agency can lead to freedom and financial stability—but only if you’re prepared to do the work. That means understanding both your earning potential and the effort required to get there. It’s not just about writing policies—it’s about building something sustainable. You need to think long-term, plan for slow months, and invest time in your operations, marketing, and growth.
You Don’t Have to Do It Alone
The journey can feel isolating at times, but the right support can ease the burden. At SIA of NC, we partner with new agency owners to provide tools, mentorship, and strategic guidance from day one. Whether it’s help with licensing, operational setup, or long-term planning, we’re here to help agencies build their legacy from the ground up.
Final Thoughts
Starting an insurance agency isn’t a shortcut to free time or stress-free work—it’s a commitment to building a business with purpose. But with the right mindset, support, and strategy, it’s also one of the most rewarding paths you can take. If you’re serious about starting an insurance agency, make sure you’re equipped with the right expectations and the right partner to help you succeed.
Watch and read more content here: Media Center | SIA of NC
SIA of NC is a Master Agency of 
. Learn more about the SIAA Model: SIAA Model | Insurance Agency Network & Alliance | SIAA